Summary:
Just as the love of Christ and the service of the Blessed Virgin Mary have brought us together in a single family, fraternal charity unites those of us still striving to lead a life of allegiance to Jesus Christ in this world, and those already awaiting the vision of God in purgatory. Today the whole Order commends our departed brothers and sisters to God’s mercy through the intercession of Our Lady, sure sign of hope and consolation, and begs for their admission to the courts of heaven.
*The Commemoration of All Carmelite Souls is transferred to November 16 this year.
A General History of the Carmelite Order:
The Carmelite Order traces its roots to Mount Carmel, where the Prophet Elijah, the Order's founder and father, confronted the prophets of Baal. After proving that God is the one true God, he slew the false prophets. On Mount Carmel, Elijah then had his servant watch until a tiny rain cloud appeared, signaling the end of the drought. Tradition says the Blessed Virgin Mary manifested herself to Elijah as that rain cloud, and the sons of the prophets built the first shrine on Mount Carmel for her.
Thereafter, Mount Carmel was revered as the place where the worship of the Only True God was defended and firmly established, and where communion with God could be sought and attained. Tradition also tells us that since the time of Elijah, at least a few people have always dwelt on Mount Carmel, dedicated to the continual seeking and worship of God. In this way, the hermits of Carmel lived as sons of the great prophet and as brothers of the Blessed Virgin. Although many consider this only a legend, Carmelites, who call on St. Elijah in prayer daily, know he is not a shadowy figure from the past. His spirit remains active in a vital tradition and shapes how we live.
During the Second Crusade, a group of Crusaders settled on the western slopes of Mount Carmel. They no longer wanted to be soldiers of an earthly army but, instead, soldiers of Christ. Among them was St. Berthold, who saw hermits living separately on Mount Carmel and scattered throughout Palestine, and organized them into a community to live in imitation of St. Elijah's life. As their superior, St. Berthold's reputation for holiness drew many, including his successor, St. Brocard. Around 1206-1214, these hermits, needing structure to preserve their way of life and protect their vocation, asked for a common rule of life. At St. Brocard’s request, St. Albert of Jerusalem laid down the spirit they had received from their predecessors in the Rule of St. Albert.
The rule condenses the entire meaning of Carmelite life in a short statement: “All are to remain in their own cells…, meditating on the Law of the Lord day and night and watching in prayer, unless otherwise justly employed.” Thus, Carmelites fulfill the Rule when they hold the image of the Lord continually before their eyes, becoming like him. In this way, we can never finish studying the Gospels.
This does not mean Carmelites forsake the Lord when they work. Rather, work is unavoidable, and, following the word and example of St. Paul, the rule commands Carmelites to earn their bread by their work. But for Carmelites, work is always a means and must never be an end in itself. So standing before the face of God remains the true content of their lives.
The rule also emphasized the importance of silence, stating:
“Sin will not be wanting where there is much talk, and He who is careless in speech will come to harm; and elsewhere: The use of many words brings harm to the speaker’s soul. And our Lord says in the Gospel: Every rash word uttered will have to be accounted for on judgment day. Make a balance then, each of you, to weigh his words in; keep a tight rein on your mouths, lest you should stumble and fall in speech, and your fall be irreparable and prove mortal. Like the Prophet, watch your step lest your tongue give offense, and employ every care in keeping silent, which is the way to foster holiness.”
Pope Honorius III approved the Rule of St. Albert in his bull Ut vivendi normam in 1226. In 1229, Pope Gregory IX confirmed this rule again and gave it the status of Regula bullata.
Shortly after this approval, the hermits were driven from Mount Carmel. Around 1240, the first convents were founded in Europe. In 1242, most Carmelites in the Holy Land were forced to leave for Europe. In 1254, King Louis IX of France returned from a Crusade and brought some Carmelites back with him, further promoting their expansion. Finally, in 1291, the Saracens took Mount Carmel. The brothers who remained, singing the Salve Regina, were put to the sword, and the convent was burnt. As a result, the Carmelites abandoned the Holy Land for about two and a half centuries.
This migration marked a crucial turning point in the Order's history, forcing it to adapt to a completely different social and religious context. In 1247, St. Simon Stock was elected General of the Order and revised the Rule, changing it from a hermitic Order to one of mendicant friars. Pope Innocent IV approved the rule that same year. The new, more flexible rule then allowed greater integration into community and apostolic life while retaining the Order's contemplative spirit. From then on, foundations were no longer restricted to deserts but might be made in cities and the suburbs of towns; the solitary life was abandoned for community life; meals were to be taken in common; abstinence, though not dispensed with, was rendered less stringent; silence was restricted to the time between Compline and Prime of the following day. The rule also encouraged more active engagement in apostolic activities, such as preaching, teaching, and pastoral service, allowing the Carmelites to play a more visible and active role in medieval Christian society.
After obtaining the rule's mitigation, St. Simon Stock opened houses at Cambridge, Oxford, London, York, Paris, Bologna, and Naples. He especially sought to establish the order around universities, partly to secure for the religious the benefits of higher education and partly to increase vocations among undergraduates.
Tradition says the Blessed Virgin appeared to St. Simon Stock on July 16, 1251, accompanied by a host of angels. She held the Order's scapular in her hands and said, "This shall be a sign unto thee, and the privilege of all Carmelites, that he who shall die piously, wearing this scapular, shall not fall into the eternal flames."
Later, in 1265, St. Simon Stock met Bl. Jane of Toulouse. She was a devout woman who, after the founding of a Carmelite monastery in the city in 1240, chose to live as a recluse near it, leading a life of great austerity. When she met St. Simon, she asked to join the Carmelites, and he agreed. Bl. Jane became the first member of the Carmelite tertiary order and received the habit from him. In Carmelite tradition, she is considered the first woman Carmelite and founder of the Carmelite Third Order. Even so, while informal associations of lay people with the Carmelites formed, it was not until 1452 that Bl. John Soreth wrote the first rule for the Third Order. Under this rule, lay people promised to follow a stricter, more dedicated way of life based on Carmelite spirituality.
Due to St. Simon Stock’s mitigated rule, the Carmelites adapted quickly and effectively to European conditions, which helped them expand. However, their rapid growth in Europe also brought challenges, and they often faced internal tensions over the balance between contemplative life and apostolic activities. At the Chapter of Nantes, a majority of Carmelites asked to appeal to Pope Eugene IV for a second mitigation of the Rule of Saint Albert. The letter, dated February 15, 1432, indicated that many professed members of the Order could no longer observe the rule because of its severity and rigor, given the fragility and weakness of the human body.
Two Carmelites were sent to convey this request to the Pope. He responded the same day with the bull Romani Pontificis. Addressed to the Prior General, Jean Faci, the bull granted the Carmelites permission to stay and walk freely and lawfully in their churches, cloisters, and adjoining places at the appropriate times; moreover, it granted the faculty to eat meat three days a week, except during Advent and Lent and on other days when this was prohibited by general law. Later, Pope Pius II completed this permission on December 5, 1469, by granting the Prior General the faculty of dispensing with fasting on days when abstinence was lifted.
Pope Sixtus IV granted greater freedom, commonly known as Mare magnum, in the bull Dum attendant meditatatione of November 28, 1476, which conceded many advantages to the mendicant orders. Yet this mitigation of the Rule met some resistance. Even before its promulgation, some protested against "a general relaxation" of the Rule.
With all these mitigations, the protective walls of separation, rigorous penance, and silence fell, and the pleasures and cares of the world pressed into the Carmelite Order. This was by no means peculiar to the Carmelites. They occurred in all the mendicant orders and awakened loud cries for reform everywhere. The first step towards reform in the Carmelite Order dates from 1413, when three convents, Le Selve near Florence, Gerona, and Mantua, agreed to observe the ancient rule. After considerable difficulty, the congregation of Mantua, as it was called, obtained in 1442 quasi-autonomy under a vicar-general. The most celebrated member of this reform was Bl. Baptista Spagnoli, who served as vicar-general six times and became general of the whole order. Although influential in the 15th century, the Reform of Mantua had limited influence until this mitigation, introduced around 1465, was definitively incorporated into the regulation of the Calced Carmelites in 1783 by Pope Pius VI.
Bl. John Soreth, who became Prior General of the Carmelite Order in 1451, carried out a similar reform. While visiting numerous provinces, he established several reformed houses, to which the most fervent religious flocked. The reform took hold in some convents. Bl. John Soreth hoped his reform would gradually be imposed in all the houses of the order. Still, this attempt remained largely unfulfilled because the prior general who followed him favored a return to a mitigated rule.
Bl. John Soreth also broadened the Order to include women. Under his governance, he obtained the bull Cum nulla from Pope Nicholas V in 1452, authorizing the Second Order, the Carmelite nuns. He established communities of nuns in the Netherlands. He then collaborated with Bl. Frances d’Amboise to found women’s communities in France. With the same bull, he also wrote the rules for the Third Order Carmelites. Around this time, the Carmelite Order also saw its first two saints canonized, St. Albert of Trapani and St. Angelus of Sicily.
The most notable reform of the Carmelite Order took place in the 16th century, initiated by St. Teresa of Ávila and St. John of the Cross, resulting in the creation of the Discalced Carmelites. The Monastery of the Incarnation in Ávila, where St. Teresa entered in 1535, followed the mitigated rule. For decades, she endured the conflict between worldly relationships and the pull of undivided surrender to God. Convinced she needed to return to the primitive rule of Carmel, with its emphasis on silence, solitude, strict enclosure, and a small, sisterly community life of manual labor, prayer, and penance, she sought to live “the evangelical counsels as perfectly as possible.” After innumerable battles and difficulties, she founded the monastery of St. Joseph in Ávila in 1562, and her reform grew from there. St. John of the Cross, another Spanish mystic, joined her reform efforts and was especially influential in establishing the male Discalced Carmelites. Together, they founded the first convent of Discalced Carmelite Friars in Duruelo, Spain, on November 28, 1568.
The Discalced Carmelites sought a more austere, contemplative form of life, inspired by the Order’s primitive rule. They practiced poverty, renouncing wealth and material comfort. Contemplative prayer and silence were central to their daily lives. They strictly observed the Liturgy of the Hours and encouraged long periods of personal prayer. Although living in community, the Discalced placed strong emphasis on solitude and interior recollection, seeking to imitate the eremitical life of the first Carmelites. They followed rigorous ascetic discipline, including fasting and other penances. St. Teresa also rekindled the Marian and prophetic spirit of the Carmelite vocation.
Although King Philip II of Spain welcomed St. Teresa's foundations, as he wanted all orders reformed according to the principles of the Council of Trent, the Discalced Carmelites faced much opposition, including from unreformed Carmelite houses. Both St. Teresa and St. John suffered much in accomplishing the work Our Lord had given them, such as when Carmelites from Toledo arrested and imprisoned St. John of the Cross in their monastery. On June 22, 1580, the Discalced Carmelites obtained from Pope Gregory XIII, by the decree Pia Consideratione, the ability to become a separate province within the Carmelite Order, thus protecting their identity. The following year, during the Provincial Chapter held in Alcalá de Henares (Spain), Fr. Jerónimo Gracia was elected as the first Provincial of the Discalced Carmelites, and their constitutions were approved. When St. Teresa died in 1582, seventeen convents of nuns (all but two personally founded by her) and fifteen convents of friars existed.
During the 17th century, the Discalced Carmelites spread rapidly throughout Europe. Bl. Anne of Jesus and Bl. Anne of St. Bartholomew, the daughters of St. Teresa, personally trained by her and St. John of the Cross, at the request of Bl. Mary of the Incarnation, founded the first monasteries of the reform in France and Belgium. Bl. Anne of Jesus was especially instrumental in preserving the reform's spirit. When Fr. Nicolò Doria, the second Provincial of the Discalced Carmelites, changed the manner of government, Bl. Anne of Jesus submitted the Constitutions of St. Teresa (already revised by the General Chapter of 1581) to the Holy See for approbation.
From these foundations in Spain, France, and Belgium, Carmel has since spread around the world like a great tidal wave of grace, including back to their original home. In 1631, the Discalced Carmelites returned to Mount Carmel in the Holy Land. Venerable Fr. Prosper built a small monastery where the Carmelites lived until 1767, when they were ordered to leave, and the monastery was demolished. They moved and built a larger monastery over the grotto where St. Elijah lived. In 1799, Napoleon’s campaign seriously damaged the new church. Sick and wounded French soldiers were cared for in the monastery, and when Napoleon retreated, the Turks massacred the soldiers and drove out the religious. In 1821, they also demolished that monastery. Finally, Br. Casini built a new monastery, which opened in 1836: Stella Maris, which is still there today.
In 1790, the first group of Carmelite Nuns came to the United States. They were three Americans and an Englishwoman from the Hoogstraet Carmel in Belgium. They first settled in Port Tobacco, Maryland, where their convent, the Carmel of Port Tobacco, still exists today.
Like many religious orders, the Carmelite Order also suffered multiple persecutions during the 19th and 20th Centuries. The French Revolution suppressed the order, dispersing the nuns into small groups who lived out of sight in private houses. At the peak of the persecution, a Carmelite convent, now known as the Martyrs of Compiègne, was executed by guillotine in 1794. The people of France attributed the end of the Reign of Terror to their martyrdom. After the disturbances ended, the wealthy heiress Camille de Soyécourt, who later became Mother Thérèse-Camille of the Child Jesus, did much to restore Carmelite life in France.
The Napoleonic secularization at the beginning of the 19th century dealt a heavy blow to the Carmelites. After Napoleon had occupied large parts of the Rhineland, almost all monasteries were dissolved after 1806; the 16 houses of the Lower German Province disappeared. The Kulturkampf in Germany from 1871 to 1878 also persecuted religious orders.
In 1936, the Spanish Civil War saw dramatic religious persecution. Churches and shrines across Spain were desecrated, burned, and looted. Furthermore, relics and statues were paraded through the streets in mock celebrations, and bodies of saints and clergy were dug up and abused. In addition, priests and religious were hunted and massacred. Notably, around 6,800 religious were murdered between 1936 and 1939, including 13 bishops. As many as 20,000 churches were destroyed. People, especially women, were murdered for attending Mass, and anyone associated with the opposition was killed. Among those martyred are Bl. Angel Mary Prat Hostench, O. Carm., who was murdered with his confreres in Tárrega in 1936, and Bl. Lucas of St. Joseph Tristany Pujol, O.C.D., who was slain with his confreres in Barcelona the same year.
World War II also saw the persecution of many religious. Among those martyred were the Carmelite priests St. Titus Brandsma, O.C.D., Bl. Alphonsus Maria of the Holy Spirit, O.C.D., and Bl. Hilary Januszewski, O. Carm. Among the most notable martyrs of the Holocaust was the Carmelite nun, St. Teresa Benedicta of the Cross. Born Edith Stein, she was Jewish and became an atheist. Earning a doctorate in philosophy, she eventually converted to Catholicism. She wrote many books, including Life in a Jewish Family, Finite and Infinite Being – An Ascent to the Meaning of Being, and The Science of the Cross, which is a commentary on St. John of the Cross. After her canonization, the Church named St. Teresa Benedicata of the Cross one of the Patrons of Europe, and the Discalced Carmelites have petitioned to have her named a Doctor of the Church.
Along with St. Teresa Benedicta, several Carmelite saints have received significant attention in the 20th and 21st centuries. St. Thérèse of the Child Jesus was beatified in 1923 and later canonized in 1925. St. Thérèse of Lisieux joined the Carmelite Order in 1888. Despite her short life, she left an immense spiritual legacy through her autobiography, Story of a Soul, and her doctrine of the "little way" of love and trust in God. She captivated hearts far beyond the Order's boundaries, not only as a worker of miracles for those in need, but also as a director of “little souls” on the path of “spiritual childhood.”
In 1926, Pope Pius XI named St. John of the Cross a Doctor of the Church. Following this, Bl. Marie-Eugène of the Child Jesus was called upon to give numerous conferences or homilies on the spirituality of the Carmelite masters throughout France, thereby contributing to the renewal of the Church in France between the two world wars. Having come to know their spiritual doctrine intimately, he published a synthesis of Carmelite Spirituality in two books in 1949 and 1951: I Am a Daughter of the Church, and I Want to See God.
Pope Paul VI declared St. Teresa of Ávila the first woman Doctor of the Church in 1970. On November 17, 1991, St. Raphael of St. Joseph Kalinowski was the first friar in the Order of the Discalced Carmelites to be canonized since co-founder St. John of the Cross was canonized in 1726. In 1997, Pope St. John Paul II also named St. Thérèse of Lisieux a Doctor of the Church. Pope Francis later canonized St. Thérèse’s parents, Louis and Azélie Martin, in 2015.
In 2015, Pope Francis also canonized St. Mariam of Jesus Crucified. Mariam entered the Discalced Carmelites in France in 1876 and was sent with the founding group to the Carmel of Mangalore in India. In 1875, she went to the Holy Land, where she built a monastery in Bethlehem. St. Mariam was noted for her supernatural gifts, especially her humility, her devotion to the Holy Spirit, and her great love for the Church and the Pope.
In 2016, Pope Francis canonized St. Elizabeth of the Trinity. She made her profession of vows in Dijon in 1903, and in 1906 the Divine Spouse called her “to light, to love, and to life.” A faithful adorer in spirit and in truth, her life was a “praise of glory” of the Most Blessed Trinity, present in her soul and loved amidst interior darkness and excruciating illness. In the mystery of divine inhabitation, she found her “heaven on earth,” her special charism, and her mission for the Church.
Today, the Carmelites of both branches have spread throughout the world. The Carmelites of the Ancient Observance include about 2,000 friars, brothers, and priests; about 800 nuns; more than 2,000 sisters; and over 9,000 Lay Carmelites. The Discalced Carmelites include about 4,000 friars, brothers, and priests; about 11,500 nuns and sisters; and about 25,000 Lay Carmelites.
The Carmelites' involvement in founding monasteries and in missions has had a significant impact on the spiritual and social life of communities around the world. Their efforts have nourished believers' faith, promoted justice and solidarity, and strengthened bonds of fraternity and peace between peoples.
Carmelites continue to bear witness to God's love and the call to holiness in today's world. Their efforts to establish places of prayer and contemplation, as well as their commitment to missions of evangelization and social development, embody the values of the Gospel and the spirit of service of the Carmelite Order.
Prayer:
Lord,
you are the glory of those who serve you.
Look lovingly on our departed brothers and sisters,
united in following Christ and his Mother
by the waters of baptism and the bonds of Carmel.
In your mercy
grant them everlasting sight of you,
their Creator and Redeemer.
We ask this through our Lord Jesus Christ, your Son,
who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit,
God, forever and ever.

Comments